Pre-order pies

Holiday pies · Burlington, Vermont

Thanksgiving,
spoken for.

  • A cookie tin of gingerbread people, iced stars and almond shortbread, tied with red ribbon
    Cookie tin · $38
  • Pie boxes tied with string stacked on a snowy porch by a green door
    Porch pick-up
Lattice apple, pumpkin and pecan pies on a farmhouse table with candles and red maple leaves
Apple lattice, maple pumpkin, bourbon pecan · 9-inch, $34–42

Order by Fri, Nov 20 · pick up Wed, Nov 25, 10–4Pre-order pies

The baking calendar

Three windows a year, and each one shuts

We bake only what is ordered, so the order-by day is the day. Pick a holiday.

Ellen’s floured hands finishing the crust of a cranberry apple pie on a board

Open now

Thanksgiving

Order by
Fri, Nov 20
Pick up
Wed, Nov 25 · 10 – 4

All six pies and the Farmhouse tin. We bake 220 pies for Thanksgiving and then we stop, so the window can close early. It closed on the 17th last year.

Pre-order pies
Two lattice pies cooling on a rack in a farmhouse window, snow falling outside

Opens Fri, Nov 27

Christmas

Order by
Fri, Dec 18
Pick up
Wed, Dec 23 · 10 – 4

The six pies plus mincemeat, which only comes out in December, and both the Small and Farmhouse tins. 160 pies this time; the kitchen is smaller in the cold.

Pre-order pies
An open tin of gingerbread stars, snowflake sugar cookies, shortbread and molasses cookies with pine sprigs

Opens Tue, Dec 1

Winter solstice tins

Order by
Fri, Dec 11
Pick up
Sat, Dec 19 · 10 – 4

Cookies only: the Solstice tin, darker and spicier, for the longest night of the year. A hundred tins, then the oven goes to Christmas pies.

Pre-order a tin

Thistle & Pine Pie Co.Pie order · season of 2026

No. 0417

Six pies, nine inches each

PieTopPriceHow many
Apple latticeCortland and Northern Spy apples from Shelburne, cinnamon, a little lemonLattice$36
Maple pumpkinRoasted sugar pumpkin, Vermont maple syrup, cream, nutmegGF crust +$4Open$34
Bourbon pecanToasted pecans, dark maple, a pour of bourbon that bakes offGF crust +$4Open$42
Cranberry appleTart cranberries and Cortlands, orange zestLattice$38
Maple creamMy grandmother’s sugaring-season pie, a soft maple custardOpen$36
MincemeatApples, raisins, currants, suet-free, soaked in brandy since OctoberChristmas onlyDouble$40

All-butter crust, rolled by hand$15 holds your order · the rest at the standSigned: Ellen

A slice of apple pie with vanilla ice cream melting on it, candles and neighbors at the table behind
Apple lattice, warmed 15 minutes, with vanilla ice cream. Thanksgiving at the Hendersons’, 2025.

Cookie tins

Three tins, packed the night before

Each tin is a real tin, lined with parchment and tied with a ribbon. Keep it for the buttons afterwards; everyone does.

  • The Small tin

    $2418 cookies

    • 6Gingerbread stars, iced
    • 6Maple shortbread
    • 6Molasses crinkles
  • The Farmhouse tin

    $3836 cookies

    • 6Gingerbread people, buttons and all
    • 6Iced gingerbread stars
    • 8Almond and orange shortbread
    • 8Molasses crinkles
    • 8Snowflake sugar cookies
  • The Solstice tin

    $4430 cookies

    • 6Spruce-tip shortbread
    • 6Black pepper ginger
    • 6Cranberry oat
    • 6Dark chocolate and sea salt
    • 6Cardamom knots
Hands lifting gingerbread people out of the Farmhouse tin
The Farmhouse tin, open. The stars go first.
The farm stand by the red barn in the snow: lanterns, pie boxes on a long table, Ellen handing one over

Pick-up

How the farm-stand pick-up works

  1. Pull in by the red barnThe lot is plowed by 9. Follow the lanterns; there are always lanterns.
  2. Say your name at the standEvery box is tied with cranberry string and tagged with the name on the order.
  3. Pay the rest, take your pies$15 is paid already. Card or cash for the rest, and a cup of hot cider while Ellen checks the box.
  4. Can’t make it by 4?Text us. Your box waits on the porch shelf under your name until 6.
© OpenStreetMap contributors
Thistle & Pine, Burlington The farm stand by the red barn. The address comes with your order. Open the map
Pie boxes stacked on the porch by a green door in falling snow
The porch shelf, 4 to 6, for anyone stuck at work.
Ellen Parrish in a plaid flannel shirt and a floury apron in her farmhouse kitchen, lattice pies cooling beside her
Ellen, the week before Thanksgiving

A note from Ellen

I grew up in the Northeast Kingdom, where my grandmother sold pies from a table at the end of the driveway every fall and kept the money in a coffee can. I was a nurse at the hospital in Burlington for twenty-four years, and for most of them I brought pies in for the night shift at Thanksgiving.

In 2018 my brother let me put a stand by his barn at the edge of town. I baked forty pies that first November and sold out by ten in the morning. People were upset. So the next year I made a list, and the list became pre-orders, and now there is a window and it shuts.

I know the window is a nuisance. It is also why every pie is rolled by hand the day before you take it home, and why nothing goes in a freezer before it gets to you. Order early. I’ll have the cider on.

Ellen

Fingers crimping the edge of a pie crust on a floured wooden table
About 1,100 crimps a pie season

From the neighbors

  • Four Thanksgivings now. My mother-in-law asked for the pecan recipe and Ellen told her, kindly, no.

    Dana, the Old North End
  • I forgot to order once. Only once. The window is real, set a reminder.

    Mike, South Burlington
  • The Farmhouse tin went to my sister in Arizona and she called to ask why the shortbread tastes like Christmas morning. Butter, I said.

    Ruth, Winooski
  • Picked up in a snowstorm with two kids in the car. Box in my hands in four minutes, cider for the kids.

    Jess, Essex Junction

Questions

Freezing, warming, and the rest

Can I freeze a pie?

Apple, cranberry apple, pecan and mincemeat freeze well for a month: cool, wrap twice in plastic and once in foil. Thaw overnight in the fridge. Don’t freeze pumpkin or maple cream; custard weeps when it thaws.

How do I warm one up?

Fruit pies: 15 minutes at 325°F, uncovered, on the lower rack. Pecan is best at room temperature. Pumpkin and maple cream are served cool, straight from the fridge.

Do you make a gluten-free crust?

Yes, for the maple pumpkin and the bourbon pecan, $4 more. It’s a good crust. But our kitchen is full of wheat flour, so please don’t order it for someone with celiac disease.

How long does a pie keep?

Fruit and pecan pies keep two days on the counter under a towel, then four in the fridge. Pumpkin and maple cream go in the fridge as soon as you are home.

I missed the deadline. Is there anything left?

Text Ellen. On the Tuesday before Thanksgiving we put a few extra pies on the stand from noon, first come, first served, and they’re usually gone by two.

What about the pie plates?

Pies come in tin plates. Bring them back any time and we take $2 off your next pie.

Pre-order

Spoken for, in three steps

Pick a pie or a tin, then its pick-up day. $15 holds it and Ellen texts to confirm. Need more than one pie? Say so in the note and she’ll add them to the same box.

  • Thanksgivingorder by Fri, Nov 20 · pick up Wed, Nov 25
  • Solstice tinsorder by Fri, Dec 11 · pick up Sat, Dec 19
  • Christmasorder by Fri, Dec 18 · pick up Wed, Dec 23
  1. 1Service
  2. 2Date
  3. 3Details
Pre-order pies

Thistle & Pine

Pie Co. · Burlington, Vermont · since 2018

The standBy the red barn, edge of Burlington
Open on pick-up days, 10 – 4

Next windowChristmas opens Fri, Nov 27
Solstice tins open Tue, Dec 1

ContactText (802) 555-0193
Instagram

Start from this design